Château Clerc Milon 2023 — Professional Reviews & Ratings

Score range (consensus)

Across major professional critics, Château Clerc Milon 2023 is consistently rated:

• 92–96 points
• Generally classified as excellent to outstanding
• Peak scores reach up to 96 points from top reviewers

This places it among the stronger Pauillac 5th growth performances of the vintage.

Major critic ratings

Jane Anson (Inside Bordeaux)

• 96 points
• Notes highlight:
  • Superb quality and energy
  • Bright, lifted dark fruit profile
  • Strong sense of tension and structure
• Emphasis on aging potential and precision

James Suckling

• 95–96 points
• Notes include:
  • Blackcurrant, chocolate, hazelnut aromas
  • Mineral and saline undertones
  • Long, dense, structured finish
• Focus on richness combined with freshness

Wine Advocate (William Kelley / Robert Parker team)

• 92–94 points
• Notes:
  • Red and black berry fruit profile
  • Spice, oak, and pencil shaving nuances
  • Medium to full body with layered texture
• Slightly more conservative but still strongly positive

Vinous (Neal Martin / Antonio Galloni team)

• 92–94 points
• Notes:
  • Cassis and blackberry-driven profile
  • Floral lift and creamy texture
  • Balanced acidity and tannin structure
• Emphasis on elegance and harmony

Jeb Dunnuck

• 92–94 points
• Notes:
  • Floral, saline, and mineral character
  • Ripe, structured tannins
  • Refined but concentrated style

Falstaff

• 95 points
• Notes:
  • Cherry, cassis, nougat, and oak spice
  • Juicy and balanced palate
  • Strong aging potential

Other aggregated impressions

• Trade merchant averages generally fall between 93 and 95 points
• Overall consensus places it in the upper tier of Pauillac 5th growth wines for the vintage

Overall professional consensus

Style

• Cabernet Sauvignon–dominant Pauillac blend
• Classic structure with modern polish
• Dark fruit core with graphite, spice, and floral elements
• Strong aromatic definition for the estate

Structure and aging

• Firm but refined tannins
• High aging potential
• Best drinking window generally estimated from around 2029 to 2050

Bottom line

Château Clerc Milon 2023 is widely regarded as an excellent to outstanding Pauillac, combining structure, precision, and freshness. It is considered one of the stronger recent vintages of the estate, with broad agreement on its significant aging potential.

Wine Advocate

The Wine Independent