Bourbon, Penelope, Wheated Whiskey

Penelope Wheated Bourbon — Professional Ratings

• Drinkhacker — 8.5/10 (B+): Notes of cornbread, butter, cinnamon apple, honey, caramel, vanilla and baking spices. The reviewer found it approachable, flavorful and particularly good value at around $40.
• The Whiskey Wash — 7/10: Sweet and smooth with caramel, honey and vanilla, balanced by subtle rye spice. At 95 proof, it is described as both bold and very drinkable, suitable for sipping or cocktails.
• Artfully Bourbon — 8/10 (“Very Good”): Creamy and rounded, with sweet tea, vanilla, toffee, toasted almond and soft oak. The four-grain mash bill and double-cask finishing add some extra texture and spice.

Summary: Professional reviews put Penelope Wheated in the good-to-very-good range, with scores of 7–8.5/10. The consistent themes are honey, vanilla, caramel, sweet grain, baking spice and a creamy, approachable texture.